Is Psychiatry Creating a Pandemic of Fake Mental Illness?

If you’re human and feel emotions, congratulations—you might already qualify for a psychiatric diagnosis. From ADHD to depression, PTSD, anxiety, and autism, labels are being handed out faster than pharmacies can fill SSRI prescriptions. But are these diagnoses real, or just a booming business dressed up as medicine?

The Rise of the “Medicalized Mind”

UK child and adolescent psychiatrist Sami Timimi warns that modern psychiatry has drifted far from science. In a provocative essay for the Globe and Mail, he argues that psychiatric diagnoses are subjective labels, not objective medical conditions. Unlike heart disease or diabetes, these labels don’t identify an underlying pathology—they function like consumer brands, expanding to cover nearly any human distress and driving over-diagnosis, particularly among youth.

Psychiatric drugs, Timimi emphasizes, act more like alcohol or narcotics than targeted treatments. Their nonspecific effects temporarily alter mood and perception, creating the illusion of improvement while masking life’s natural ups and downs. Social contagion, vague diagnostic criteria, and media hype only amplify the problem, encouraging self-diagnosis and over-medicalization of normal human experiences.

The Cost of Over-Diagnosis

According to Timimi, terms like “neurodiversity” or “having ADHD” mislead families into believing that ordinary behavioral differences are diseases. Common struggles—difficulty focusing, occasional anxiety, or grief—are being labeled as lifelong conditions needing lifelong medication. Meanwhile, real-life stressors like poverty, discrimination, and unstable housing are ignored, replaced by a psychiatric narrative that pushes drugs over understanding.

The consequences are dire. Antidepressants, especially in youth, can double the risk of suicide. Yet pharmaceutical companies and uncritical practitioners continue to market them as precise solutions. Large studies like the U.S. STAR*D antidepressant trial, touted to justify polypharmacy, have been criticized as misleading and wasteful—costing millions while reinforcing dangerous myths.

Resilience Over Medication

Timimi’s clinical experience tells a different story: many young people recover without heavy medicalization. Families who normalize distress, provide patience, and accept children as they are see far better long-term outcomes than those who rush to label and medicate. Concept creep—turning normal sadness into “depression” or shyness into “social anxiety”—creates dependence on psychiatric intervention and obscures the real causes of suffering.

Help keep this independent voice alive and uncensored.  Buy us a Coffee

The psychiatrist calls for a cultural shift. Mental distress should be recognized as part of the human experience, not a lifelong disease. Reducing the influence of pharmaceutical interests, resisting overdiagnosis, and supporting natural coping strategies could prevent countless unnecessary harms and save lives.

If psychiatry embraced this perspective, fewer lives would be lost to suicide, fewer people disabled by medication, and more families could focus on real understanding rather than prescriptions. The warning is clear: the Mental Health Industrial Complex may be causing more harm than it cures.